Ingredients 1 oz. Baileys Irish cream 1/2 oz. apple schnapps 1/2 oz. butterscotch schnapps 2 oz. half-and-half or whole milk coarse sugar ground cinnamon Instructions 1. Rim glass with coarse sugar mixed with cinnamon. 2. For each cocktail, pour all ingredients into a drink shaker. 3. Fill shaker with ice then shake and strain cocktail into a chilled glass, with or without ice.